Here's an idea.
I haven't thought it through at all, but I figured I'd give it a go here and see what you all thought.
I'll start a poll, yes a poll. It will list all the top recommended names to me (privately or not) of users that the site masses would like to see removed from the site. We'll all vote anonymously, and at the end of the week we'll remove that person.
The caveat here being that I'll put the moderation staff on that list as well. And if they are in fact selected, aside from myself, we'll have no moderation happen for a week either.
We'll make it so only old accounts with certain criteria met can vote in order to insure fairness. Campaigning will be promoted but only in the open forum.
I'm quite certain it'll be a good time and remind us all of being 4 year olds and picking someone we hate for a day only to pick someone else the next.